Being charged is frightening. This guide walks you through what to expect — and what to do — in plain, honest language.
Don't Say Anything Until You've Spoken to a Lawyer
This is the single most important piece of advice for anyone who has been charged or is being questioned by police. You have the right to silence under Australian law, and you should use it. Anything you say to police — including things that seem innocent, explanatory, or helpful — can be used against you in court. Even well-intentioned statements can be taken out of context, misunderstood, or used to contradict your defence at trial. Politely but clearly tell police you will not answer questions until you have spoken to a lawyer. You do not need to be confrontational — simply state your position calmly and maintain it. Police are trained interviewers; you should have legal advice before engaging with them substantively, regardless of how straightforward the situation may seem.
What Happens at the Police Station
After being charged, you will either be released on bail (with conditions such as reporting to a police station, surrendering your passport, or not approaching certain people) or held in custody pending a bail application before a court. If bail is refused at the police station, your lawyer can make an urgent application to the Magistrates' Court for bail to be granted or conditions to be varied. In Victoria, if bail is refused in the Magistrates' Court for certain serious offences, an application can be made to the Supreme Court. The grounds for refusing bail include the risk that you will fail to appear at court, reoffend, or endanger the safety of the community or specific individuals. A lawyer can present a bail plan addressing each of those concerns and significantly improve the prospects of bail being granted on acceptable terms.
The Difference Between Summary and Indictable Offences
Australian criminal law divides offences into two broad categories: summary offences and indictable offences. Summary offences — including minor traffic matters, minor assaults, and public order offences — are heard and finalised in the Magistrates' Court before a magistrate sitting alone. Indictable offences — including armed robbery, serious assault, drug trafficking, sexual assault, and murder — are heard in the County or Supreme Court before a judge and sometimes a jury. Some offences are 'hybrid', meaning they can be dealt with as either summary or indictable depending on circumstances or election. The distinction matters significantly: sentencing powers in higher courts are substantially greater, and the preparation, procedural steps, and costs of those proceedings are considerably more complex and time-consuming than Magistrates' Court matters.
The Court Process — What to Expect
Most criminal matters begin in the Magistrates' Court. Your first appearance is typically brief — the charge is formally read, bail conditions are addressed if needed, and the matter is adjourned for further preparation. Depending on the seriousness of the charge, the matter may be finalised in the Magistrates' Court or committed to the County or Supreme Court for a contested hearing or sentencing. Your lawyer will advise you on your plea options and help you understand the realistic range of outcomes for your specific charge and circumstances. Pleading guilty at an early stage typically results in a sentencing discount — usually 10–25% — because it saves victims the trauma of giving evidence and conserves court resources. Contesting a charge proceeds to a hearing where witnesses are called, evidence is tested, and the court determines guilt.
Sentencing — What the Court Takes Into Account
If you plead guilty or are found guilty at trial, the sentencing stage determines the penalty. Victorian courts sentence under the Sentencing Act 1991 and must balance multiple competing purposes: deterrence (both general and specific), denunciation of the conduct, rehabilitation of the offender, and protection of the community. The judge or magistrate will consider the seriousness of the offence and the circumstances in which it occurred; your personal circumstances including age, mental health, employment history, and family responsibilities; any prior criminal history; the impact on victims (including any Victim Impact Statements filed); your prospects of rehabilitation; and whether you demonstrated genuine remorse and co-operated with authorities. Your defence lawyer can make detailed sentencing submissions, call character witnesses, tender psychological or other expert reports, and ensure the court has a full picture of your circumstances beyond the offence itself.
Diversion, Plea Negotiations and Alternatives to Conviction
Not every criminal matter ends in a conviction on the original charge. For first-time offenders charged with less serious matters, the Magistrates' Court Diversion Program in Victoria offers a pathway to complete specified conditions — counselling, community service, or a letter of apology — in exchange for the charge being withdrawn without a conviction. Eligibility depends on the offence type, the prosecutor's agreement, and the accused accepting responsibility for the conduct. Separately, plea negotiations between your defence lawyer and the prosecutor can result in a charge being amended to a less serious equivalent, related charges being dropped, or an agreed statement of facts that characterises the conduct more accurately. These negotiations typically happen before a formal plea is entered and can significantly affect the sentencing range. Even where a conviction is unavoidable, your lawyer can advocate for an alternative sentencing disposition — such as a fine, community correction order, or treatment program — rather than a term of imprisonment.
What a Criminal Defence Lawyer Actually Does
A criminal defence lawyer does far more than appear in court on your behalf. From the outset, they will obtain full disclosure of the prosecution's evidence and assess its strength and any weaknesses. They will identify procedural defects — unlawful searches, improper questioning, failures to adhere to your rights under the Evidence Act or Crimes Act — that might result in key evidence being excluded. They will advise you on your realistic prospects at trial and the likely sentencing range if you plead guilty. They will negotiate with prosecutors where there is room to do so. At hearing or sentencing, they will present your case in the most favourable possible light, cross-examine prosecution witnesses, and ensure the court applies the law correctly. Throughout the entire process, they will explain what is happening at each stage so you can make fully informed decisions — which is your right.
Need Legal Advice on This Topic?
Our experienced criminal law lawyers are ready to help. Get expert, transparent legal advice.